The two favourite trail shoes of the wide-toebox crowd, built on opposite philosophies of what should happen under your heel. The Speedgoat 5 (87/100) stacks 32mm of soft 25 HC foam on a 4mm drop — maximum protection for rocky miles and ultra distances. The Lone Peak 8 (84/100) runs zero-drop with a modest 25mm stack and firmer 32 HC foam — ground feel and natural mechanics over plushness. The Altra is 34g lighter (264g vs 298g) and slightly wider (102mm vs 100mm); the Hoka is the burlier, more protective platform. Both around $140–$155.
Hoka Speedgoat 5 | Altra Lone Peak 8 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $142 | $128▲ Best |
| Weight | 298g | 264g▲ Best |
| Heel drop | 4mm | 0mm |
| Heel stack | 32mm | 25mm |
| Midsole feel | 25 HC | 32 HC |
| CoreScore | 87▲ Best | 84 |
| Arch support | neutral | neutral |
| Best for | Mountain runs, Technical terrain, Ultras | Ultra running, Zero drop transition, Wide forefoot |
| Not ideal for | Fast flat trails, Road running | Runners transitioning from heel-drop shoes, Speed races |
Who should buy which
Choose the Speedgoat 5 for long distances, technical rock, and any time cushioning is protective equipment — it's the shoe that saves your legs at hour six.
Choose the Lone Peak 8 if you're committed to natural-gait running or thru-hiking — zero drop and ground feel are the whole point. Transition gradually if you're coming from conventional shoes; your calves will invoice you otherwise.
Not sure which fits yourfeet? Answer 7 quick questions and we'll rank every shoe in our catalogue for your exact profile.
Take the 2-minute finder quiz